The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern-18, "Clean-Up--a compilation of corrections, additions and miscellaneous correspondence & Bricks"
Publication Information
- Date Original
- 2007-07-29
- Contributor
- Barbara Brackman Legacy Project
- Location
- Lawrence, Kansas, United States
- Description
An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Pattern.
- Text File
- Transcript
The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern A Digital Newsletter for 2007
© Barbara Brackman 2007 (For copyright information see the bottom of this message)
July 29, 2007
18
Clean Up---a compilation of corrections, additions and miscellaneous correspondence & Bricks
Early Quilts Do go back to issue # 3 on the subject of hexagon quilts and fix a date. I wrote the earliest example I'd seen was 1817, but in the Rhode Island book I found an example dated 1807.
Several people wrote with references to early quilts (1770-1830) that weren't on my list of date-inscribed American patchwork. In another email today I am going to update the lists of quilts from 1770-1820 which were originally in newsletters # 10, 11 and 12. It's copyright free so you can share it with students and friends.
Hazel Carter pointed out an American strip-set quilt dated 1817 at the American Museum in Bath. This is the earliest date-inscribed strip quilt so far and corroborates all the date-attributed examples we've seen.
Pam Conklin reminded me of the 1795 Jane Travers Gatewood medallion pictured in the West Virginia Heritage Quilt Search book. This quilt has numerous stars pieced of diamonds, much earlier than the 1822 and 1823 examples I mention in # 13. We have to conclude that eight-pointed stars pieced of diamonds are very early patchwork designs.
Several readers mentioned the 1782 quilt now on display at the Winterthur, which was pictured in Orlofsky on page 36. But the label at the exhibit this summer says it was made in Europe, so I did not include it. You might want to add it to your list of eighteenth-century American quilts since the origin is in doubt, but note that it is different in appearance from the documented American quilts.
Star of Bethlehem/Rising Sun Several readers mentioned date-attributed examples of the Star of Bethlehem that are earlier than the 1839 date-inscribed example cited in issue # 1. This quilt is on my original database of date-inscribed quilts from the 1980s and the only information I have about it is that it was made by Haines in New Jersey. Kimberly Wulfert writes about one in Kiracofe & Johnson's book (page 77) that has a label dating it to 1832, but this label was added after the maker's death in 1876.
There are many date-attributed examples of the Rising Sun that go back to the turn-of-the nineteenth century. See the next email for some pictures. We have to conclude either: a) They were not being made before the 1830s and all those earlier date attributions are wrong. b) They were being made earlier and by coincidence we have not come across a published example dated before 1839.
Pattern Sources Nancy Hornback remembered where I saw the third example of a trio of appliqued floral quilts. It's in Anita Schorsch's Plain and Fancy on page 64. The Shelburne has one with pattern names on it (see issue # 6), Carolyn Miller owns a similar example without the names (see issue #14 More Pictures) and the one in Plain and Fancy, made to recall Lila Goodrich Lerch of Union County, Pennsylvania, is dated 1850.
Regarding pattern blocks (issue #15) Julie Silber recalled buying Mary Stickler's Quilt, the amazing Mariner's Compass quilt that she and Linda Reuther named their quilt shop after.
"The owner, Florence Harrison---Mary Strickler's grandson's wife---gave us a few other items: A photo of Mary herself, Mary's hymn book and a single quilt block, also made by Mary Strickler---a Caesar's Crown....She called it a 'pattern.' I had never heard that term, so I asked her about it. She seemed surprised that I didn't know---and told me that 'women always made one block to keep as a pattern.' Mrs. Harrison was about 80 years old in 1970."
Quilt Names Broken Dishes In 1891 Adelaide Harriet Osgood wrote the following about the land around Stafford, England. "they have cut old Stafford into more curious patterns than a grandam's 'broken-dish' patch-work quilt."
Dresden Plate After writing about Dresden Plate quilts and possible sources for the name, I read the Minnesota project book and found their thoughts about the pattern name---popular culture I hadn't heard of.
"Around the turn of the twentieth century…women attending carnivals and dances did wear embossed flower-shaped decorations or cotillion orders that looked very much like the quilt pattern. These decorations, called Dresdens, were often used as Christmas ornaments as well."
Nine Patch/Irish Chain There have been questions about the difference between a nine patch and an Irish Chain. When is it just a nine patch? What defines it as an Irish Chain? There are 3 things I always say about pattern names:
- is a quote from Florence Peto: "It is not wise to be didactic about the nomenclature of quilt patterns."
2 ) We have no idea what long-dead quiltmakers called their patterns unless they left the name on the quilt or in a document like a letter or will.
- Classifying a design as a nine-patch or an Irish Chain assumes we have hard and fast boundaries between the categories. I took several linguistic courses in graduate school and here's what I learned: There are very few categories that have defining boundaries everyone can agree about. I was going to mention male/female as one that everyone can agree about---but then I decided gender is a category with some very fuzzy edges---edges that get fuzzier the more we learn about genetics.
Fruit vs. vegetable is the classic categorization that makes one realize how fuzzy boundary edges are. There are objects we KNOW are fruits—apples for one. There are objects we KNOW are vegetables---carrots are right in the center of the vegetable category. But what about rice and tomatoes. They lurk around the fuzzy edges of the categories. Their classification depends on how you define the category and there are many definitions.
If we use the fuzzy boundary edge idea to think about Nine Patches and Irish Chains we can say that a classic two-block Double Irish Chain is right in the center of the Irish Chain category. A nine-patch alternating with a plain block is on the fuzzy edge. There is no right or wrong answer about quilt pattern names. One curator's Irish Chain is another's Nine Patch.
Oh excuse me, I'm being didactic.
Thanks to all the alert readers.
Page 3, Issue 18
Pattern Tracking: Brickwork Attachments: early brickwork.jpg Two early brick quilts constructed with white "grout". The more pastel version is a crib quilt 35 x 44" from M. Finkel and Daughter (Quilt Engagement Calendar 1992); the one with the star border was from Thomas K. Woodard's stock, made by Amy McCoun Carpenter, of Brooklyn, New York. 71 x 93" (Quilt Engagement Calendar 1988). I would guess the "grout" is pieced. These certainly have much in common with the more randomly pieced Stonewall or Tile Quilts described in issue #15.
Brick early oa.jpg Brick early det2.jpg An early version of the Brickwork or Brickwall quilt that looks to be from the 1840-1860 period, sold on eBay.
One thing I've learned from surfing eBay is the popularity of the rectangular pattern called Brickwork or Brickwall. You can find two or three at any time, some so commonplace they are worth only a few dollars; others advertised as "African-American---Gee's Bend style" demanding hundreds of dollars. Most appear to have been made from 1900 to 1960 but see the attachment brick early oa.jpg for an earlier example. The earliest dated example I've found is in the Illinois project book. Eliza Purdy's two-color brickwork quilt is dated 1813.
This simple all-over pattern of rectangles was quite popular for utilitarian quilts and tied comforters about 1900. Many were made from samples torn from swatch books, particularly rectangular wool samples. Some needleworkers decorated the rectangles with the linear embroidery stitches that were also popular for crazy quilts, but most who made brick patchwork valued utility over ornament. The majority of the rectangular designs were tacked or tied into what were called camp quilts, sougans or haps, depending on the regional slang.
In 1882 English needlework writers Caulfeild and Saward described rectangular samples as "textiles…attached to large cards. They are all cut in oblong
Page 5, Issue 18
parallelograms---that is to say the length is double that of the width of each…These samples are sometimes disposed of for the making of Patchwork Quilts, or given away in charity for the same…."
Tailor's sample cards were not new in 1880. In the eighteenth century Benjamin Franklin experimented with light absorption and color to see if light clothes were indeed cooler in summer. For fabric: "I took a number of little square pieces of broadcloth from a tailor's pattern card of various colors." In 1845 Daniel Webster wrote a friend: "Did you ever see a tailor's pattern card, on which he puts his samples of various colors for waistcoats?"
By 1900 fabric was more commonplace and so were pattern sample cards, often bound into books. Quilters also cut their own rectangles of wools, denims and dress-weight cottons. Some used a penny postcard for a pattern, combining two fads. During the Kansas Quilt Project we heard people call these quilts pieced of rectangles "postcard quilts".
The Ladies' Art Company carried a pattern they called Brickwork in their early catalogs at the end of the nineteenth century. Their design was more a medallion of rectangles than a conventional wall of bricks. In 1889 Good Housekeeping published an article by Mrs. F.A.W. who offered to send a paper block of many patterns, among them Brickwall. In her 1929 book Old Patchwork Quilts and the Women Who Made Them, Ruth Finley pictured a Brickwall also called Hit an' Miss. She was quite confused about pattern origins, however, describing it as an outgrowth of crazy quilts, what she believed to be the earliest design. Her Darwinian theory imagined amoeba-like crazy shapes evolving into regular rectangles.
We do see rectangular shapes in the borders of some of the earliest quilts. They were particularly popular for borders in British quilts, but as an all-over design the majority were made about 1900-1925.
Mystery Pattern: Diamond/String variation. Estimated date 1890-1920. Years ago, Rhoda Cohen sent me this photo of a very odd thing to do with strings and diamonds.
EBay Item of the Week This Texas dealer has a way with words and exclamation points. She often shows brick quilts which she calls Stacked Bricks. I haven't seen a published source for that name but it seems to be used quite a bit. http://cgi.ebay.com/ANTIQUE-VINTAGE-1940s-WOOL-PRAIRIE-STACKED-BRICK-QUILT_W0QQitemZ110152050928QQihZ001QQcategoryZ63632QQssPageNameZWDVWQQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
Links The Quilt Index has 17 quilts categorized as "Brick." Here's one of the best---from the Tennessee project. /quilts/22-18-1899/ To see the other 16 go to www.quiltindex.org and search for brick.
Page 7, Issue 18
The International Quilt Study Center has several examples classified as Bricks, one as Brickwall and two from India as Bricks variation. Go to www.quiltstudy.org and search for the keyword brick. Or try clicking on this to see a nicely composed medallion variation http://www.quiltstudy.org/includes/photos/quilt_database/large/2006_043_0173.jpg
References: Sophia F.A. Caulfeild & Blanche C. Saward. The Dictionary of Needlework: An Encyclopedia of Artistic, Plain and Fancy Needlework. (London: A.C. Cowan, 1882) Reprint. Detroit: Singing Tree Press, 1971. Page 434.
E. Duane Elbert and Rachel Kamm Elbert, History from the Heart: Quilt Paths Across Illinois (Nashville: Rutledge Hill Press, 1993) Page 2
Roderick Kiracofe and Mary Elizabeth Johnson, The American Quilt: A History of Cloth and Comfort 1750-1950 (New York: Potter Clarkson, 1993)
Minnesota Quilt Project, Minnesota Quilts, Creating Connections to Our Past (Stillwater, MN: Voyageur Press, 2005) Page 172.
Fawn Valentine, West Virginia Quilts & Quiltmakers: Echoes from the Hills (Athens: Ohio University Press, 2000) Page 20.
Anita Schorsch, Plain and Fancy: The Country Quilts of the Pennsylvania Germans (New York: Sterling Publishing, 1992 )
Copyright information. All rights to the text and information in this newsletter are reserved by Barbara Brackman. Subscribers may print the files and save them digitally. Subscribers may not forward the files or post the information on any websites or bulletin boards without written permission. You may quote up to four sentences without written permission and refer to information if proper attribution is given. Please use the reference: "Barbara Brackman, The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern, 2007, digital newsletter.
"Brick variations--- all from the twentieth century. 10 attachments.
1904 rowlands sig.jpg 1904 rowlands.jpg Brickwork quilt signed and dated, Elizabeth Rowlands, 1904. From eBay. I didn't save an overall shot but this version with a central focus is like the design the Ladies Art Company called Brickwork Quilt about 1890.
strip rectangles.JPG strip rect det.JPG This quilt from eBay is tessellated---one rectangular shape repeated---but arranged in a different manner. About 1890 the Ladies Art Company catalog called a similar design Fine Woven Patchwork. They also showed a fragment of another design called Twist and Turn that might be the source.
strip o bricks2. jpg In this quilt from eBay the design is not a tessellation. Triangles finish off the rectangles to create a straight edge.
lfisher barkcloth.jpg A top of rotated rectangles pieced from barkcloth, the tropical upholstery fabric from the 1940s and '50s. From Laura Fisher Quilts.
tellford brick.jpg A very orderly version that looks to be about 1910 from Betsy Telford's Rocky Mountain Quilts website.
bricks stripJPG.JPG A related version from eBay, but it does that great visual thing of setting up a regular pattern and then forgetting about it.
mennon brick.jpg bricks.jpg Both from eBay. These are tessellations but shading in the Mennonite version makes it puzzling. The other makes the most of rotation and a lot of print variation.
Attached is a Word file "Early Dated Quilt.doc". If you want to save this click on it and then click "Save As" and put it in a file named Early Dated Quilts in a folder where you can find it . My pc computer would automatically give it a meaningless title and put it in a temporary file and I would never be able to find it again.
7 Picture Attachments long janehall oa.jpg Long JaneHall det.jpg Jane Hall sent these snapshots of a Star of Bethlehem quilt that is pictured in the North Carolina project's book. The family attributed it to 1806 but the documenters thought it might be ten years later---one of the many date-attributed examples before 1839. See Ellen Fickling Eanes, Erma Hughes Kirkpatrick, et al., North Carolina Quilts (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1988) Page 106.
risingsun lcpq15.jpg Here's a page from Ladies' Circle Patchwork Quilts Magazine # 15--- a long time ago. The quilt is attributed to Baltimore in 1790 and belongs to the Tucson Museum of Art. It's unlikely that it's 1790. The dogtooth triangles are Turkey red, something you really don't see that much of until the 1830s.
library of congress .jpg Here's an old black and white photo taken at a crafts show and now in the digital files of the Library of Congress that shows a corner of the 1795 Jane Travers Gatewood quilt.
BrokenDishesCenter...jpg Album Quilt with Broken Dishes center---or Broken Dishes quilt with album block border. Estimated date 1860-1890. After reading about Broken Dishes last week Laura Fisher sent this picture.
Cord ACMiller oa.jpg Cord ACMiller date.jpg Single Irish Chain or Double Nine Patch, signature quilt made for Anna Cripe Miller, date-inscribed 1906, Flora, Indiana. Photo from Xenia Cord. Xenia sent this picture of a dated quilt made for the wedding of a German Baptist woman.
Early Date-Inscribed Patchwork Quilts Attributed to America Barbara Brackman & other Quilt Detectives Not copyright 7/2007 Feel free to photocopy
Eighteenth Century Patchwork Quilts 15 quilts
177_ R Porter. American Museum in Bath. Shiela Betterton, Quilts and Coverlets from the American Museum in Britain (Bath, England: The American Museum, 1978), page 51. Block, pieced Star, applique dogtooth, swag & basket border.
1783 Deborah Wilson. Daughters of the American Revolution Museum #60.56 http://www.quiltindex.org/basicdisplay.php?pbd=dar-a0a0g7-a Central focus but block style with variety of pieced and appliqued stars.
1785 Anna Tuel, by her mother. Wadsworth Atheneum. Central focus with pieced wheel center, appliqued hearts, broken dishes borders.
1786 Elizabeth Bowman Nace, Heritage Center Museum of Lancaster Co. Block, Nine Patch, strip border.
1787 Rachel Mackey. 1988 Sotheby's Auction. Medallion, crewel emb. center, pieced star & sawtooth borders
1789 Memphis Museum ??? This was on a list of quilts Sally Garoutte shared. I couldn't check it.
1793 Mary Johnston. Winterthur Museum. Patsy and Myron Orlofsky, Quilts in America (New York: McGraw Hill, 1974) Figure 34. Medallion applique tree of life center, pieced geese and appliqued bow knot and swag borders,
1795 Jane Warwick Gatewood, Fawn Valentine, West Virginia Quilts and Quiltmakers, page 20. Medallion, cut out chintz center, diamond stars, bowknot borders.
1795 M. Campbell. Smithsonian Institution. http://americanhistory.si.edu/collections/quilts/18th.htm Medallion reverse applique w/ pieced borders
1795 Mary Jones. Quilt Engagement Calendar, 1988, plate 52. Medallion with crewel emb. center , broken dishes borders.
1795 Art Institute of Chicago. A Tree of Life ??? Could not check this.
1796 E W(ebster). Gloria Seaman Allen, "Bed Coverings: Kent County Maryland, 1710-1820," Uncoverings 1985 (Mill Valley, CA: American Quilt Study Group, 1986) page 25. Medallion, plain fabric center, squares and rectangles in borders.
1797 Hannah John. Ladies Circle Patchwork Quilts. Maine issue. Medallion, applique center with stars and dogtooth borders.
1798 Ann Taylor. Gloria Seaman Allen, First Flowerings: Early Virginia Quilts (Washington DC: D.A.R. Museum, 1987). Page 30.
Medallion, crewel emb. center, stars and melon shaped blocks in borders.
1798 Magdellan Howell Davis, Maumee Valley Historical Society, Maumee, Ohio. Pictured in Quilts at Meadowbrook Hall catalog. Medallion Star Center, pieced sawtooth and chained square borders.
Patchwork Quilts 1800-1810 21 Quilts
Date Maker Source Style
1800 Drum Pennsylvania State Museum Medallion star
1801 Moffit Baldwin Ledger 1/27/1982 ?
1803 Eby Maryland Project, page 37 Medallion basket
1803 ? Online auction Block 9 Patch on point
1803 Taylor Mus Early Southern Dec Arts Medallion chintz
1804 Stites Roan, Pennsylvania Medallion pieced
1804 ? Online auction Medallion 9-patch center
1806 Selleck Connecticut Project, page 17 Block 9-Patch
1806 ATE Old Sturbridge Basset page 65 Block 9 Patch
1806 Roe Smithsonian Institution cat. Pg 24 Block 9 Patch
1807 Hunt Rhode Island Project, page 21 Mosaic Hexagon
1807 EDB Bishop, Knopf Guide pl 152 Medallion Pieced Letters
1807 Bradford Henry Ford Museum Medallion Eagle
1808 Foster Orlofsky Fig 79 (149) Medallion Eagle
1808 Winsor Old Sturbridge Village Mosaic Hexagon
1809 MC Hersh Uncoverings 1982 Block Checked Wool
1809 Glover St.Louis Art Mus. Orlofsky p 46 Medallion Hewson
1809 Stouffer Dunton page 229 Pl 93 Medallion Cut-out Chintz
1809 Thompson IQSC 1997.007.0257 Medallion Cut-out Chintz
1809 Elder Valentine Museum ? from Sally Garoutte's list
1810 Gundacker Herr, Fig 43, Heritage Lanc. Co. Med/Block pieced/ chintz
Patchwork Quilts 1811-1820 14 Quilts Date Maker Source Style 1811 Cincinnati Art Museum Med/Block Hewson stars
1812 MMT eBay auction June 2007 Medallion app vase
1813 IQSC # 2003.003.0383 Med/Block Star & 9 patch appl. Leaf border
1813 Purdy Illinois project, page 2 Mosaic, Brickwork
1813-4 Robinson cornucopias Shelburne #140 Med. Appl tree/life,
1814 Schenck Lanc.Co Herr fig 49 Block 9 Patch
1814 Kapp Pennsylvania Hist Mus 31.63.6 Mosaic Hexagon
1815 Mathewson RI proj. pg 25 Block 9 Patch
1817 Marple Roan & Roan pg 26 Mosaic Hexagon
1817 SG Amer Mus Bath pg 27 Strip 9 Patch
1818 Brigham Conn. Project pg 26 Medal. Appl w/ alligators
1818 Ann Daggs Smithsonian Medallion Appl vase
1818 EW Henry Ford(Safford/Bishop f.239) Block, reel w/ appl blocks
1818 Somerville Spencer Museum of Art Med. Princess Feather
Patchwork Quilts 1821 to1830 20 quilts Date Maker Source Style 1821 Ellery Historic Deerfield Mus. Strip Hexagon Mosaic
1822 Warner NY Historical Soc. Block Irish Chain & App
1822 Nowlan Smithsonian Medallion Crewel emb.
1823 Lauck DAR Museum Medallion Sawtooth chintz
1824 Taylor Colonial Dames GA Medallion Chintz
1824 Turner IQSC 1997.007.0342 Medallion Flying Geese
1824 McCreary Ft. Bend TX Museum Med/block Star/ 9 Patch
1825 Hodgson QNM July 2007 Med. Crewel emb. Broken Dishes
1825 C.A.C. Ill. State Univ catalog Medallion Pieced
1826 Harris Uncoverings 1982 p.31 Tree of Life medallion
1826 Johnson Shelburne# 10-283 Med/block Pieced star
1828 Whelpton Qut.Eng.Calendar year? Medallion Conv. Applique
1828 For Griffin Los Angeles County Block Irish Chain
1825-30 Valentine Smithsonian Block Irish Chain
1829 Buckingham Maryland Historical Society ??
1830 Marion Mus, Early Southern Decorative Arts Block Irish Chain
1830 Miller Peto Amer. Quts. Plate II Med. Chintz Tree of Life
1830 Schleifer/Kichlein Moravian Museum Winterthur 3 similar quilts, Reel, crewel emb, block
- Object ID
- 64-193-101
Related Records