The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern-21, "Regional Patterns: Eagles & Pennsylvania"
Publication Information
- Date Original
- 2007-08-19
- Contributor
- Barbara Brackman Legacy Project
- Location
- Lawrence, Kansas, United States
- Description
An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Pattern.
- Text File
- Transcript
The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern A Digital Newsletter for 2007
© Barbara Brackman 2007 (For copyright information see the bottom of this message)
August 19, 2007
21 Regional Patterns: Eagles & Pennsylvania
A quote from Aunt Phillis's Cabin or Southern Life As It Is by Mary Henderson Eastman (Lippincot, Brambo & Co, 1852, page 114) Fiction describing the work of an enslaved woman named Phillis: "The quilt…contained pieces of every calico and gingham dress that had been worn in the Weston family since the revolution, and in the centre had been transferred from a remnant of curtain calico [cut-out-chintz?], an eagle with outstretched wings."
Attachments: Ford mus eagle.jpg .Eagle applique inscribed 1807, Esther S. Bradford, Montville. Connecticut. Collection of the Henry Ford Museum.
Copake 19thc coverlet.jpg . Wool embroidered coverlet.
Eagles are among the earliest images on American quilts. Attached is a small photo of a date-inscribed eagle quilt dated 1807. It looks embroidered but the caption in Safford and Bishop where the quilt is pictured in a good black and white photo says, "a magnifying glass will soon prove it is really all applique!" It's quite large, 102 by 99 inches.
Also attached is an eagle coverlet made from the same pattern that I found on the Copake online auction house. The piece looks to be wool embroidery, considerably smaller than the Bradford quilt and without the dog-tooth (or Vandyke scalloped) edge and fringe that the quilt has.
There's an appliqued Tennessee eagle quilt dated 1808 in a private collection that's pictured in the Orlfosky book (Plates 149 and 150 in the new edition). It's signed Rebecah Foster, Nashville, October 5, 1808. Anita Schorsch's The Art of the Weaver pictures it in Figure 8 and includes a transcription of the poetry embroidered on the quilt. One verse: Long as the Stars their courses run Or Man beholds the circling Sun May God o'er fair Columbia reign And crown her counsels with success With peace and joy her Eagles bless And all her sacred rights maintain.
The Museum of American Folk Art has a whitework spread with a similar eagle in candlewick. These designs may have been copied from another source (patriotic porcelain from China and England pictured similar eagles) or may have been drawn by the professional pattern drafters described in issue # 14.
Page 3, Issue 21
Pattern Tracking: The Four Block Eagle Attachment: Reunion eagle.jpg. A few years ago Nancy Hornback and I both made reproductions of the four-block eagle. Mine is the large one; Nancy's the smaller. The picture is from the cover of an out-of-print Sunflower Pattern Co-operative pattern. I called it a Reunion Eagle, reflecting the connection to the Centennial rather than the Civil War.
One exceptionally popular eagle design was a four-block applique of large eagles with shields on their breasts arrayed around a smaller central motif. Quilt historian Florence Peto, writing in The Magazine Antiques in 1940 described the design as a "not uncommon type that goes by the name of Union Quilt…popular during the Civil War---north of the Mason-Dixon line, of course. In fact the making of Union Quilts seems to have been localized in the state of Pennsylvania."
Peto's source was Ruth Finley who published a similar statement in 1929. To our better-educated eyes they look to be post-war needlework, probably from about 1875 to 1925. Today's conventional wisdom is that they are related to the Centennial Exposition held in Philadelphia in 1876. While they are found all over the U.S., Finley's observation about a regional origin is probably true. The Kansas Quilt Project, surveying the entire state, found one such quilt. Pennsylvania's Oral Traditions Project, surveying a four-county area north of Harrisburg found about 36 examples, the earliest attributed to 1876.
It seems every regional pattern must have one or two glaring exceptions to the regional rule. See the next email for an Indiana eagle.
These particular eagles rarely carry the attributes of the official American eagle, who holds arrows in one talon symbolizing war and laurel leaves in the other for peace. In fact this eagle seems to have an identity problem. Is he eagle or dove? In his beak he often carries an olive branch, like the peaceful dove that appears to Noah in the Biblical story of the flood. The eagle image may have had meaning other than patriotism to the quiltmakers. In some German religious traditions the eagle with wings spread represented God's protection.
Pattern collectors haven't found a published pattern, so we conclude quilters shared the design hand to hand, following certain conventions. The set is usually four blocks---four eagles around a medallion center with a border of dogtooth triangles, an echo of the earliest quilts. Not only are the borders stitched using the dogtooth method, but the spiky edges of the eagles wings and tails are often slashed and folded rather than being carefully marked and basted. The medallions in the center are also appliqued using a slash and turn technique as are any stars.
A possible image source is a group of jacquard woven coverlets from the last quarter of the nineteenth century. Like the quilts, the coverlets feature a medallion center flanked by four eagles with leaves in their beaks, a sprinkling of stars and a border of triangles. The woven eagles, however, often clutch arrows and laurel leaves. In an exhibit catalog of Canadian coverlets curators Harold and Dorothy Burnham showed several examples woven by different Canadian weavers with jacquard pattern cards, which they described as "the nineteenth century equivalent of 'painting by numbers,' a considerable amount of know-how was required, but little originality. ..It was one way that a small workshop could compete economically with mass-produced goods." Coverlet weavers purchased the cards for popular designs. Did the factory-made coverlets inspire the hand-made quilts? Or vice-versa?
Page 5, Issue 21
Mystery Pattern Hagerstown eagle.jpg Peggy Armstrong snapped pictures of this eagle quilt at a Hagerstown, Maryland auction ten years ago or so. It looks to be 1870-1900 and one quiltmaker's quirky idea, but see the next email for a picture of an almost identical quilt in the collection of the Henry Ford museum. A third one from the America Hurrah quilt dealers appeared in a Quilt Engagement Calendar.
Events: The Chicago History Museum has a quilt exhibit up until December 12th. Quilts: A Patchwork History looks to contain antique and contemporary quilts. Try these links to find out about the show. www.chicagohistory.org http://www.pioneerlocal.com/newsstar/entertainment/452639,dy-quilt-070407-s1.article
EBay Item of the Week Gb eagle top.jpg GB-Best Antique Quilts is an eBay dealer from Pennsylvania that has 2 of these 4-block eagle quilts for sale right now. The top in the attachment is different in that the eagles are white on a red ground. The floral in the corners is unusual too. http://cgi.ebay.com/1900s-PA-Eagles-Applique-ANTIQUE-QUILT-RED-WHITE-BLUE_W0QQitemZ140129707695QQihZ004QQcategoryZ63628QQrdZ1QQssPageNameZWD1VQQcmdZViewItem#ebayphotohosting
Links Here's an example of the four-block eagle quilt from the Michigan State University Museum at the Quilt Index. The color scheme is rather odd but it contains the eagles, the central motif and the border of triangles. The eagles are holding a flower that looks like a sparkler. It is missing the stars which sometimes float around the edges. /quilts/12-8-8336/
2 jacquard coverlets from ontario http://ebybook.region.waterloo.on.ca/getArtifact.php?AID=10314 http://ebybook.region.waterloo.on.ca/getArtifact.php?AID=10400&personID=I15201#
A star quilt from dealer Stella Rubin's website. The stars look to be cut out and stitched using the slash and turn method found in many of the four-block eagle quilts. http://www.stellarubinantiques.com/items/623826/item623826store.html#item
The Art Institute of Chicago has an important quilt collection that has rarely been seen. They have an on-line catalog now that contains 36 quilts. Among the highlights: Several Bertha Stenge quilts and a date-inscribed whole cloth calimanco dated 1778. These whole-cloth quilts aren't often dated. http://www.artic.edu/aic/collections/citi/search?keyword=quilt&artist=&title=&mainrefnum=&Search=Search
References: Harold B. Burnham and Dorothy K. Burnham, Keep Me Warm One Night: Early Handweaving in Eastern Canada (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1972) Page 357.
Jeannette Lasansky, In the Heart of Pennsylvania . (Lewisburg, Pennsylvania : Oral Traditions Project, 1985) Page 13, 14, 34.
Jeannette Lasansky, Pieced By Mother: Over 100 Years of Quiltmaking Tradition. (Lewisburg, Pennsylvania : Oral Traditions Project, 1987) Page 28.
Anita Schorsch, The Art of the Weaver (Universe Press, 1978).
Copyright information. All rights to the text and information in this newsletter are reserved by Barbara Brackman. Subscribers may print the files and save them digitally. Subscribers may not forward the files or post the information on any websites or bulletin boards without written permission. You may quote up to four sentences without written permission and refer to information if proper attribution is given. Please use the reference: "Barbara Brackman, The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern, 2007, digital newsletter."
zellers indiana.jpg Four Block Eagle, stamped in ink: "Mary A. Zellers, Winamac, Ind". Dealer Sandra Mitchell found this quilt years ago and published it in The Quilt Digest 5 where an estimated date of 1870-1890 was given. One wonders if Mary A. Zellers had roots in Pennsylvania. Her quilt fulfills the definition of the pattern in question: there are 4 eagles holding something in their beaks around a central medallion. But the eagles are holding other fowl, an unsettling picture.
ford mus womensday.jpg Another version of the mystery pattern from the Henry Ford Museum, pictured in Woman's Day magazine and Rose Wilder Lane's Woman's Day Book of American Needlework.
memorial hall coverlet.JPG Another of the jacquard woven coverlets from the Centennial. This one pictures a building at the Centennial with eagles in the air. Note they hold an olive branch in their beaks.
The rest of the jpgs are examples of the four-block eagle which can be pretty loosely interpreted. This pattern is a great example of how much freedom of expression quiltmakers can exercise while sticking to the pattern's rules.
More About Snakes The JPGs labeled Fisher are all courtesy of dealer Laura Fisher.
reno pieced snake.jpg is from Beth Reno who said she bought it from a Mississippi dealer who'd bought it from the maker's grandson, an old man. The maker had lived in Norris Chapel, Tennessee. The family name was "Path of Life."
And a lovely note from Cuesta Benberry "I want to tell you a completely undocumented experience I had with the Snake's Trail design. Years ago, probably 50+ when I first became interested in quilts, I went over to Edwardsville, Illinois Historical Society to what was rare then - an exhibition of antique quilts from residents in the area. One quilt with the undulating design I did not recognize (being fairly new to quilts, there were many designs I did not know anyway) but this one fascinated me. The signage said "Snake's Trail" - don't recall the date. I took a snapshot of the quilt. On my next trip to Kentucky to see my inlaws- who knew all about quilts and often teased me because I knew so little. I planned to confound them with the photo. I showed it to them and they just glanced at it and asked "Where did you get that Snake's Trail quilt?" Needless to say my feathers fell.
They did go on to tell me when that trail was set on a green background it was called Snake In The Grass. Sometime later after I met Mrs. Danner and we began a correspondence, I showed her that design, which she promptly called "horrid." I cracked up not because she disliked the design but I had never heard any person use that term out loud, thought it was reserved only for Victorian novels like EAST LYNNE or other sentimental stories.
Years later Yvonne Khin and her husband U Khin had a column in one of the Tower Press magazines- perhaps QUILT WORLD or QUILT WORLD OMNIBOOK, perhaps one of the others, I do not remember now. But I knew Yvonne and had corresponded with her. I think she showed that design by another title and I wrote and gave her the additional title of Snake's Trail. The following year she published a quilt wall calendar and included the Snake's Trail name with the pictured design. i think U Khin also listed the name in his quilt magazine column, but not sure as memory hazy now.
But I have always held a spot in my heart for the Snake's Trail design because of my early experience getting my comeuppance in trying to baffle my quiltmaking in-laws!!! Cuesta
- Object ID
- 64-193-104
Related Records