The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern-23, "Christian & Patriotic Symbolism plus Pine Burrs"
Publication Information
- Date Original
- 2007-09-02
- Contributor
- Barbara Brackman Legacy Project
- Location
- Lawrence, Kansas, United States
- Description
An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Pattern.
- Text File
- Transcript
The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern A Digital Newsletter for 2007
© Barbara Brackman 2007 (For copyright information see the bottom of this message)
September 2, 2007
23 Christian & Patriotic Symbolism plus Pine Burrs
The two most obvious symbolic references in American quilts are patriotism and Christianity, images that changed over time. The Liberty Pole and Liberty Cap that symbolized the Revolution were featured in many Baltimore album quilts made in the 1840s and '50s, but the Civil War encouraged Union designs in the North so Union flags and Union shields became popular, replacing the earlier concepts. The use of eagles, among the earliest quilt imagery, also increased at that time.
When Karla Menaugh and I compiled pictures of sampler quilts made in the 1860s we noticed that many with flags, stars and other patriotic designs also featured religious symbolism. Refer to the sampler quilt sent in issue #22 from Susan Parrish Antiques, which included an Odd Fellows' chain, a flag and a Christian cross. We found a few samplers from the 1860s that included the three symbols of faith, hope and charity---a cross, an anchor and a heart---at least in our interpretation.
The samplers of the 1840s probably had just as much religious symbolism but like the patriotic symbolism it isn't as easy for us to interpret. An open book (a Bible) or a laurel branch doesn't communicate religious meaning today as clearly as a cross. In the same way, a Liberty Cap is more obscure than a Union shield. It seems that the Civil War created a change in imagery that has remained in our visual vocabularies.
It's also important to recall that symbolism is too often only in the eye of the beholder. See the attachment africindian uwisc.jpg for a quilt that might be easily misinterpreted. Does that cross symbolize Christianity?
Attachments: sampler w flag.jpg Numerous samplers with flags survive from the 1860s---during and after the Civil War. Note the Christian cross on the bottom row.
cross_aa-1a.jpg There seems little doubt that the maker intended her quilt to symbolize her religion.
africindian uwisc.jpg A detail of a quilt from the website of the University of Wisconsin. See the next email for a picture of the maker with the overall shot of the quilt.
Pattern Tracking: Pine Burr quilt slavequilt_lg.jpg http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/roadshow/series/highlights/2004/savannah/hour2.html The attachment shows a quilt featured on the television show Antiques Roadshow in 2004. Click on the link to see a write-up of the segment. The website and the television show, both still circulating, tell the owner's story that this quilt in a design that most collectors call Pine Burr or Pineapple Cactus is a slave-made South Carolina quilt from the 1840s or '50s featuring an African motif that represents divine protection. The appraiser valued it at $40,000 to $60,000.
Page 3, Issue 23
The quilt is none of the above. It's probably from 1880-1920; the pattern is a relatively common one at that time and $1,000 would be a nice price. It is, however, likely to be from South Carolina. The earliest published references to the design are in two pattern catalogs from about 1900 . There are several variations---the arms can have curved or straight lines, the center can be a four patch, nine patch or plain. The Ladies Art Company (#404) called one version Philippines (a possible reference to the recent Spanish American war) and another Philadelphia Patch (#492). Clara Stone called it Pine Burr, the name which seems to have stuck. Others published names from the 1930s: Double Pineapple, Pineapple Cactus and Pine Cones. Those of you from the North might not know that a Pine Burr is a Pine Cone, an image that seems quite appropriate for the spiky edges of the design.
Causal observation indicates it is another of the end-of-the-century designs popular with Southern quilters, but if this is true, one has to wonder how Clara Stone in Boston heard about a Pine Burr. It's not an easy design to piece. Like many of the other regional patterns popular in the South at the time it has a lot of small, triangular pieces, and it's often pieced in solid color cottons that have a tendency to fade to tan.
Mystery Pattern
Wagners swirl.jpg Joan Badami sent a picture of a quilt she had made and asked me the pattern history. It was one I'd seen only once before. About 20 years ago Carole Normile of Denton, Texas, sent me a sketch of an old red and white quilt in the same pattern, made in the 1930s by Elizabeth Rousseau Caton who came to Texas from Alabama. It's somewhat like the Snail's Trail or Indiana Puzzle design made of four-patches and half-square triangles---all straight line piecing that appears to be curves. But this pattern is actual curves, a pattern drafting feat.
Joan found the recently published pattern in Debra Wagner's book All Quilt Blocks are Not Square (the black & white drawing). Wagner says it was originally called Swirl and in the book calls it Candy Swirl.
Joan says: "I met one other quilter who told me the pattern is from the South and was popular in the latter part of the 19th century. Her family is from Arkansas and they called it "Swirlyque". I truly enjoy a challenge in piecing and have just finished my 7th Swirl."
The red and white sketch in the attachment is Carole's; the black and white is Debra Wagner's. The construction is quite a bit different but the effect is the same.
EBay Quilt of the Week maine flag.jpg This quilt sold at the Julia auction house for over $20,000 last week. It had a good provenance from a Maine family and Union sentiments quilted into it. But the pattern was published in Peterson's Magazine at the beginning of the Civil War. I wonder if the buyers or the sellers realized that there are more like it out there.
Links http://wcudigitalcollection.cdmhost.com/cdm4/item_viewer.php?CISOROOT=/p4008coll2&CISOPTR=1316&CISOBOX=1&REC=12 The Hunter College Library has a small digital exhibit of Frances Goodrich's work in folklore. The women she recorded apparently sold quilts in the Pine Burr design in he 1930s.
A classic Pine Burr quilt in the Quilt Index website from Quilts of Tennessee made about 1900. /quilts/22-18-270/
Copyright information. All rights to the text and information in this newsletter are reserved by Barbara Brackman. Subscribers may print the files and save them digitally. Subscribers may not forward the files or post the information on any websites or bulletin boards without written permission. You may quote up to four sentences without written permission and refer to information if proper attribution is given. Please use the reference: "Barbara Brackman, The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern, 2007, digital newsletter.
uwisc.jpg A portrait of the woman who made the cross quilt shown in the previous email. She is a Siddi, an African-Indian woman living in Goa, India. Although I know nothing about Siddi religion I am guessing in this case a cross is just a symmetrical shape.
Link to University of Wisconsin exhibits on textiles over the past few years including the 2005 show on the quilts of the Siddi. file:///C:/Documents%20and%20Settings/Photos/newquilts%20ideas/uwisc.htm
pineburr.jpg Pine Burr, detail, made about 1883 by Virginia Ann Cooper Landreth, Peoria, Arkansas. This quilt was pictured in Arkansas Quilts. The tan points were probably once green or blue, dyed with new synthetic dyes that often faded to a dun color with light or washing. The Arkansas book has a wonderful array of late-nineteeth century Southern quilts. Arkansas Quilter's Guild, Inc. Arkansas Quilts: Arkansas Warmth. Paducah, KY: American Quilters Society, 1988.
Hall's papers.jpg This very odd quilt with some very odd images was pictured in a black and white print among Carrie Hall's miscellaneous papers in the collection of the Spencer Museum of Art at the University of Kansas. I've saved a photocopy for years thinking I'd see something else like it. I assume the crosses are Christian symbolism, but it is mysterious.
- Object ID
- 64-193-106
Related Records