The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 17, "Cross Stitch & Cotton Embroidery Thread"
Publication Information
- Date Original
- 2005-06-19
- Contributor
- Barbara Brackman Legacy Project
- Location
- Lawrence, Kansas, United States
- Description
An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
- Text File
- Transcript
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework A Digital Newsletter © Barbara Brackman 2005 (For copyright information see the bottom of this message)
June 19, 2005
17 Cross Stitch & Cotton Embroidery Thread
Embroidery as the primary decorative technique. Embroidery tends to be secondary to appliqué, piecing or foundation piecing in quilts until the 1880s, when outline embroidered quilts became popular, a topic discussed next week.
In 1986 and 1987, the Kansas Quilt Project looked at quilts made up to that point. Of quilts with the dates inscribed on them, a relatively small sample, we found 66 examples in which embroidery was the primary decoration. Only one was made before 1910. We saw three from the teens, and twelve made in the 1920s. The numbers dropped in the 1930s. We saw none from the '40s and four dated in the '50s, an interesting distribution that runs counter to conventional wisdom, which supposes that embroidered quilts were most popular in the 1930s and '40s. The greatest number of date-inscribed, embroidered-only quilts was from the 1980s---38. Twenty-nine of those were cross-stitched, indicating the recent popularity of that technique.
Cross Stitch Embroidery. Cross Stitch embroidery is common in both pre-Civil War quilts and in mid-twentieth century quilts, but you can quickly learn to see the differences in eras because the function, the type of thread and the size of the stitches are quite different. Cross stitch was the common signature or "marking stitch" on early quilts. It was not a popular decorative technique for quilts until the mid-twentieth century, when pattern companies that wanted to meet the demand for "Colonial"-style quilt designs adapted cross stitch to depict floral and geometric designs, similar to those done in embroidered samplers.
Cross stitch found in older quilts was of fine thread, most often a single strand of sewing thread, done as counted thread embroidery. The seamstress covered a specific number of warp and weft threads with each thread; the stitches would be, by necessity, rather small. Twentieth-century cross stitch is usually of multi-colored, multi-strand embroidery floss. The designs have been printed on the cotton by the pattern company or transferred using a hot iron transfer, and the needleworker---rather than counting the threads on the background fabric---embroiders over each printed X in comparatively large stitches.
The Kansas Quilt Project found 40 dated examples of cross-stitch decorated quilts, one dated in the 1950s and three in the '60s. The fashion increased in the 1970s with seven, and we saw 29 made between 1980 and 1987. The numbers might have been skewed so late because there was a trend in the '80s for inscribing dates on quilts, encouraged by teachers and magazines. More dated quilts in the '80s would result in more dated, embroidered quilts. But those numbers indicate the widespread popularity of a style that wasn't reflected in the era's quilt books and magazines.
Cotton Embroidery Thread. Although cotton dominated both the American textile market and the American quilt in the nineteenth century, cotton embroidery thread did not replace silk and wool as the favored decorative thread until the early twentieth century. Until about 1910, cotton thread was available in only a few colors. In 1882, English needlework writers Caulfeild and Saward indicated that silk threads were available in many colors, but cotton embroidery thread came only in red or blue. The 1902 Sears catalog offered only red, black, navy blue and white embroidery cotton. The red, dyed with the Turkey red process and advertised by a logo of a turkey with the word RED on his chest, was the preferred color, probably because it was considered the fastest.
According to Arts and Crafts textile historian Diane Ayers, the Richardson Silk Company introduced mercerized cotton floss in colors for about half the price of silk in 1912. (Mercerization, discovered in 1844 is a process of treating cotton with a caustic soda, an alkali solution that improves strength, color absorption, smoothness and lustre.) Like much of needlework fashion, this innovation was due to a combination of technology, trade and taste. Technology may have been the major cause for the time lag in colorfast embroidery thread. Perhaps manufacturers hadn't reliable enough purples, greens and oranges to offer a wide palette of color, but sewing-weight thread and cloth seemed colorfast enough to market prior to 1910. Perhaps a functional mercerizing process to imitate silk's lustre wasn't available for cotton thread until that date.
International trade may have been a more important factor. With silk sewing thread in a variety of colors available relatively inexpensively in the last quarter of the nineteenth century, little demand for cotton thread might have existed. The inexpensive filoselle made of waste silk, although rather low-luster when compared to more expensive silk thread, was shinier than mercerized cotton. But, after China's Boxer Rebellion in 1900 and the international trade embargoes of World War I, silk's availability decreased and the price increased. Needleworkers unable to afford silk were willing to substitute the cheaper cotton thread.
Taste also may have been a factor, as new style embroidery began to appear in periodicals and pattern catalogs. In 1916, Ruby Short collaborated with children's author Thornton Burgess to publish a series of quilt patterns. "The Bed-Time Quilt" featured embroidered animals from Burgess's stories outlined in rather cubistic fashion. The pattern was popular; many examples survive, generally embroidered in red or blue cotton thread on white cotton. In the early 1920s, Ruby Short McKim's "Bed-Time Quilt" blocks began appearing in other papers, possibly the first syndicated newspaper quilt pattern series. She and many other pattern designers soon began offering a variety of themed embroidery series, designed to be stitched in multicolored threads. The multicolored cotton embroidered quilt became an increasingly popular style in the 1920s.
Cotton thread for embroidery was sold as floss, a loosely plied thread, and as a twist in varying weights. One heavyweight twist, used for crochet, quilting and embroidery, is Pearl Cotton, tightly twisted and mercerized to produce a strong, shiny thread. Although cotton thread in a sewing weight had been used before the Civil War for marking quilts with names and dates and for details of stems and flowers, heavier cotton twist or floss for signatures or decorative designs is a good clue to a date after 1880, and cotton embroidery thread in a variety of colors an indication of a date after 1910.
Clues You Can Count On.
- Quilts with cross stitch as the major decorative element tend to date from after 1950.
- Cotton embroidery thread (generally in red and then blue) tends to date from after 1880.
- Embroidery done with a variety of colors tends to date from after 1910, and probably most likely after 1920.
Link. Quilt dealers who sell on the web are a great source for looking at quilts. www.antiquequiltsource.com has excellent photos and detailed descriptions. To see several cotton embroidered quilts, click on their "Good Buys" pages1 & 2. Because cotton-embroidered quilts aren't valued as high as other techniques, the sale section is often a good place to see them. On the "Good Buys 2" page note the Eagle quilt #5660, a cross-stitch embroidered quilt from a kit in the 1950s. This is the kind of decorative cross-stitch that was not a 19th-century technique. Scroll through all their pages to see various kinds of decorative embroidery.
References Diane Ayers, Timothy Hansen, et al, American Arts and Crafts Textiles (New York: Abrams, 2002) Page 91.
Copyright information. All rights to the text and information in this newsletter are reserved by Barbara Brackman. Subscribers may print the files and save them digitally. Subscribers may not forward the files or post the information on any websites or bulletin boards without written permission. You may quote up to four sentences without written permission and refer to information if proper attribution is given. Please use the reference: "Barbara Brackman, The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 2005, digital newsletter."
Page 3, Issue 17
Attachment. Skeins of embroidery floss and twist atop an album quilt block with a cross-stitched signature. The Turkey red album block, which uses counted cross stitch in a sewing-weight thread as a marking technique, probably dates from 1840 to 1860. The skeins are 20th-century embroidery threads. They all date from after 1910, and may be as late as the last half of the 20th century. Labels include Clark's, Star, DMC, Bucilla (a popular embroidered quilt kit maker) and Royal Society, a reference to Britain's Arts & Crafts needlework guild. Most of the skeins are floss. Some are 6-strand and some are 4. The purple and tan are a twist.
- Object ID
- 64-193-17
Related Records