The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 37, "Shape and Plain Edging"


Publication Information

Date Original
2005-11-06
Contributor
Barbara Brackman Legacy Project
Location
Lawrence, Kansas, United States
Description

An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.

Text File
Transcript

The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework A Digital Newsletter

© Barbara Brackman 2005 (For copyright information see the bottom of this message)

Last week's was really #36 and this one is really #37.

November 6, 2005

The topic for November is Edging. The manner in which a quilt is finished can provide some clues to date, and can be especially useful when trying to determine if an old top has been quilted later.

#37 Shape and Plain Edging

Cut-out Corners. Most quilts are rectangles or squares. One exception is the T-shaped quilt with cutouts in the corners to allow the spread to fit around the foot posts of a four-poster bed. Cut-out corners are a functional adaptation that correlates with bed style. Four-poster beds fell out of fashion in the 1840s, replaced by what were called “French Beds” or open beds with headboards and footboards rather than posts. Quilts with the corners cut-out to accommodate the posts tend to date from before 1860.

There is a regional exception to this rule, however. In the 1990s, I saw a quilt contest at the Vermont Quilt Festival with recently made entries from around the state. Some of the contemporary quilts were T-shaped with the cutouts for the four-posters. When I asked the locals about this shape, certainly odd to the western eye, they seemed to take it for granted. My theory is that as people left New England for the west, they took their bedding, but not their beds. They bought new-style open beds in their new homes and made quilts to fit them. People in New England still have the old family four-posters and are still making quilts to fit. Therefore, the rule on T-shaped quilts must be amended. Quilts with cut-out corners tend to date from before 1860 (unless the quilt is from New England where it might date to the 21st century.)

Scalloped & Sculptured Edges. Another exception to the square or rectangle is the quilt with a curved scallop or angular sculpted edge. The rule on shaped edges is that they tend to be a clue to a post-1925 date, although there are 19th-century exceptions. Edges with sculptured edges are difficult to bind but using an applied binding cut from the bias of the fabric results in a curved binding that lies fairly flat. Once manufactured bias tapes began to be marketed for crafts in the 1920s (more about this topic later), sculptured edges with odd angles and curves became an important part of the look of a sophisticated quilt. The use of a scalloped edge is a weak clue to a quilt made after 1925; there are too many exceptions to make it a hard and fast rule.

Applied, Straight-Grain Binding. The standard edge for American quilts is a separate piece of narrow fabric cut on the straight grain of the fabric and stitched to the top of the quilt by hand or machine, then folded over the back and secured by hand or machine. In the database I developed of dated American quilts from 1750 to 1950, I found straight grain binding on quilts dated from 1781 to 1946, with no apparent patterns of popularity.

A few observations on edges may help build a case for a particular date. 19th-century quiltmakers were more inclined to use a narrow binding. Whether it was the back brought to the front or a strip of applied fabric, very little of the binding fabric showed on the top. Quilters working after 1900 tended to use a wider binding. Since 1975 or so, quilters have collectively decided that the standard binding should be a double layer of fabric that exposes a half inch or more of fabric on the top. Quilters and quilt judges feel that these bindings, already thick because they are two layers of fabric, must also have a layer of batting extending into the binding. The result is a wide, puffy binding, often done in a contrasting color, sort of like a final border for the quilt composition.

Earlier quiltmakers had different standards. Their bindings tend to show a quarter of an inch on the top or less, stitched from a single layer of fabric and rather flat, often with no batting in the binding. Over the years, I have tried to imitate this binding in my reproduction quilts. It is not easy to obtain an edge as flat and narrow as those seen in the mid-19th-century masterpieces. One reason may be that our fabrics are stiffer due to mercerization, sizing and other fabric finishing techniques.

I also haven’t the necessary needlework skills. 19th-century quiltmakers knew how to make a rolled hem or a handkerchief hem, described as a finish for a linen sampler by Therese de Dillmont in her 1886 book. A rolled hem was “begun by rolling about 3/8 of an inch of the material as tightly as the fabric will allow.” Once the fabric is rolled with raw edges tucked inside, the rolled edge is secured by a blind stitch. Dillmont also suggested several colored embroidery stitches to finish off the rolled hem, something not seen in quilts, but it may be that many of the very narrow bindings we see in old quilts are rolled rather than folded.

Although a binding of straight-grain applied fabric is of no real use in dating a quilt, the width and thickness of that binding can differentiate between a 19th and a 20th century quilt. This information is also very useful in determining if an antique top has been quilted and finished recently. Of course, it might also indicate that an old, worn binding has been recently replaced.

Miscellaneous Edges. An applied straight grain binding is the most common 19th-century edge treatment, but one also sees quilts finished with no additional piece. Many quilters cut the backing fabric of the quilt a bit larger than the top and brought the back over the top to create a hemmed edge, what quilt historians generally call “back over front.” The reverse of that edge, which is less common, is to bring the front of the quilt to the back creating a hem on the back. So far, no one has done an analysis of the prevalence of these kinds of bindings to indicate either date or region.

Knife Edges. Many quilters used what quilt historians today call a knife edge, in which there is no applied binding. The quilter cut the back and the top the same size, both larger than the batting, and turned in the raw edges of the fabrics, securing the seam by hand with a whip stitch or by machine with a running stitch. Again, no one has done enough research on the technique to help with quilt dating or region---with two exceptions.

In her study of 19th-century quilts of Northern England, Dorothy Osler has found “the traditional finish was to turn edges in, matching the two folds, and stitch them together with one or two rows of stitches.” In the North Country, this edge is known as the butt edge or the knife edge. Twentieth-century quilters used the machine. She notes that machined edges fell out of fashion about 1950 and the women returned to hand-stitched edges, often including piping, something we do not see in the U.S. at that time. Knife edges, then are a clue to a British origin, a good piece of supporting evidence if quilting style, color palette and setting style (especially a medallion or strip format) indicate British taste.

The second use of a knife edge to determine regional and chronological origins is in today’s patchwork quilts made for export in China, India and other foreign countries. These quilts, often sold for $40 at department and discount stores, have been on the market since about 1990. Either to save fabric or because the stylists were ignorant of American binding traditions, the earlier of these foreign-made quilts almost always had a knife edge. There are other clues to the imported quilts, among them very fluffy batting and very large and sparse quilting stitches, but the knife edges are a red flag. Observation indicates that those being imported now sometimes have an applied binding, an unfortunate change. Future quilt historians will have a more difficult time differentiating between domestic one-of-a-kind quilts and mass produced imports when both have applied bindings.

Faced Edges. Very occasionally one comes across a quilt with a faced edging, much like the method used today to finish a collarless neck hole in a blouse (there’s a word that’s falling out of use.) The quilter uses a strip of straight-grain applied binding but rather than folding it so half shows on the front and half on the back, she pulls the entire strip to the back and secures it with a blind stitch or hem stitch. The edge of the quilt has a neat knife-edge seam and the front shows nothing. This faced method is so rare it seems of no use as a dating clue.

Clues You Can Count On:

  1. Quilts with cut-out corners tend to date from before 1860 (unless the quilt is from New England where it might date into the 21st century.)

  2. An applied binding that is thick and wide on the edge of an antique quilt is a clue that an old top has been quilted and finished later---or at least bound recently.

  3. A knife edge on a quilt of recent fabrics indicates a mass-produced foreign quilt made for export made after 1990 or so.

Links: The Smithsonian Institution has a website with a good deal of information about the sewing machine. Go to www.sil.si.edu/ On the Smithsonian Institution Libraries

Page 3, Issue 37

home page you’ll see a sewing machine image with the words “Industry and Technology.” If you click on that you’ll see a menu with at least three related entries, “Early Sewing Machine History” and two on Sewing Machines. If you click on Sewing Machines you’ll get a page that has the menu item “Explore the Collection.” This is an enormous digitized library of sewing machine literature, which you can search by manufacturer, so if you want to know more about an old Montgomery Wards machine you can browse by that name.

Events: The word is that the Shelburne Museum’s traveleing quilt show, Art of the Needle, scheduled to hang at the Wichita Art Museum in early 2006 has been postponed at that venue for over a year. Their website www.wichitaartmuseum.org now has the show scheduled for October 14, 2007 through January 13, 2008.

References: Therese de Dillmont, The Complete Encyclopedia of Needlework, originally published, 1886. (Reprint Philadelphia: Running Press, 1978) Page 104.

Dorothy Osler, North Country Quilts: Legend and Living Tradition (Durham, England: The Bowes Museum, 2000), Page 86.

Copyright information. All rights to the text and information in this newsletter are reserved by Barbara Brackman. Subscribers may print the files and save them digitally. Subscribers may not forward the files or post the information on any websites or bulletin boards without written permission. You may quote up to four sentences without written permission and refer to information if proper attribution is given. Please use the reference: "Barbara Brackman, The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 2005, digital newsletter."

Attachment: Two quilts showing the standard edge of straight-grain fabric. The quilt at the bottom of the photo was appliqued and quilted about 1850; the one at the top pieced possibly in the 1930’s. It’s a pieced rose, an unusual pattern to be done so late---although not done too well. The binding and quilting style indicates this pieced rose has been recently quilted. The batting is thick and so is the tan check binding (the back brought to the front), although you really can’t see it in the photo. The tan binding is somewhat wider than the old binding, but if the two edges are held up and viewed crosswise, the new binding is almost twice as thick as the old.

Object ID
64-193-39

Related Records

The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-11, "Cut-Out Chintz or <em>Broiderie Perse</em> Appliqué" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-11, "Cut-Out Chintz or Broiderie Perse Appliqué" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book <em>Clues in the Calico</em>, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-00, Index thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-00, Index An index for The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needleworkthe digital subscription newsletter published by Barbara Brackman in 2005.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-01, "Fancy Quilting" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-01, "Fancy Quilting" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-04<em>, </em>"Plain Quilting" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-04, "Plain Quilting" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-02, "Quilting Techniques" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-02, "Quilting Techniques" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-03, "Stuffed and Corded Quilting" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-03, "Stuffed and Corded Quilting" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-05, "Machine & Miscellaneous Quilting" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-05, "Machine & Miscellaneous Quilting" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-06, "Piecing by Hand and Machine" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-06, "Piecing by Hand and Machine" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-07, "Template Piecing and the Overcast Stitch" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-07, "Template Piecing and the Overcast Stitch" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-08, "The Sewing Machine & Piecing" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-08, "The Sewing Machine & Piecing" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-09, "Miscellaneous Machine Stitches" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-09, "Miscellaneous Machine Stitches" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-10, "Conventional Applique" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-10, "Conventional Applique" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 12, "Appliqué Stitches" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 12, "Appliqué Stitches" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 14, "Machine Appliqué" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 14, "Machine Appliqué" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 15, "Crewel & Wool Embroidery" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 15, "Crewel & Wool Embroidery" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 17, "Cross Stitch & Cotton Embroidery Thread" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 17, "Cross Stitch & Cotton Embroidery Thread" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 16, "Silk, Rayon & Seam, Covering Embroidery" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 16, "Silk, Rayon & Seam, Covering Embroidery" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 13, "Miscellaneous Appliqué Techniques" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 13, "Miscellaneous Appliqué Techniques" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 18, "Outline Embroidery" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 18, "Outline Embroidery" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 19, "Foundation Piecing, Log Cabins & Delaine" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 19, "Foundation Piecing, Log Cabins & Delaine" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 20, "Crazy Quilts Part 1" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 20, "Crazy Quilts Part 1" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 21, "Crazy Quilts Part 2" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 21, "Crazy Quilts Part 2" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 22, "Other Foundation Piecing & Show Quilts" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 22, "Other Foundation Piecing & Show Quilts" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 23, "String Quilts, Paper Foundations & Contained Crazies" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 23, "String Quilts, Paper Foundations & Contained Crazies" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 24, "Tied Comforters Before 1875" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 24, "Tied Comforters Before 1875" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 25, "Terms for Tied Quilts" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 25, "Terms for Tied Quilts" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 26, "Tied Quilts & Quilt Tops 1875-1950" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 26, "Tied Quilts & Quilt Tops 1875-1950" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 27, "Summer Spreads & The Two-Sided Quilt" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 27, "Summer Spreads & The Two-Sided Quilt" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 28, "Cross-Stitched Inscriptions" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 28, "Cross-Stitched Inscriptions" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 29, "Inked Inscriptions" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 29, "Inked Inscriptions" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 30, "Miscellaneous Inscriptions" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 30, "Miscellaneous Inscriptions" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 31, "Surface Embroidery in Inscriptions" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 31, "Surface Embroidery in Inscriptions" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 32, "Folded, Gathered & Tucked Quilts (Part 1)" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 32, "Folded, Gathered & Tucked Quilts (Part 1)" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 33, "3-D Techniques Part 2, Folded and Frayed" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 33, "3-D Techniques Part 2, Folded and Frayed" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 34, "Plush Work and Raised Embroidery" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 34, "Plush Work and Raised Embroidery" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 35, "Painted and Stenciled Quilts" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 35, "Painted and Stenciled Quilts" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 36, "Found Objects Incorporated into Quilts" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 36, "Found Objects Incorporated into Quilts" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework The archive of the 2005 weekly digital newsletter, The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 38, "Bias Binding" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 38, "Bias Binding" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 39, "Fancy Edges: Knotted and Knitted, Corded and Fringed" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 39, "Fancy Edges: Knotted and Knitted, Corded and Fringed" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 40, "Other Edge Treatments: Tapes, Cuffs and Prairie Points" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 40, "Other Edge Treatments: Tapes, Cuffs and Prairie Points" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 41, "Batting: Cotton, Wool, and Miscellaneous Fillings" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 41, "Batting: Cotton, Wool, and Miscellaneous Fillings" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 42, "Quilt Backing: Muslin & Domestic Cloth" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 42, "Quilt Backing: Muslin & Domestic Cloth" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 43, "Quilt Assembly Quirks" thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 43, "Quilt Assembly Quirks" An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
The Quilt Detective: Clues in Style thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in Style The archive of the 2006 weekly digital newsletter, The Quilt Detective: Clues in Style
The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern The archive of the 2007 weekly digital newsletter, The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern
The Quilt Detective: Prints, Color and Dyes thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Prints, Color and Dyes The archive of the 2009-2010 weekly digital newsletter, The Quilt Detective: Prints, Color &Dyes
The Quilt Detective: Style Clues in Date-Inscribed Quilts thumbnail
Kansas The Quilt Detective: Style Clues in Date-Inscribed Quilts The archive of the 2011 weekly digital newsletter, The Quilt Detective: Style Clues in Date-Inscribed Quilts
Barbara Brackman Legacy Project thumbnail
Legacy Barbara Brackman Legacy Project Lawrence, Kansas, United States Brackman's is a respected quilt historian specializing in the visual aspects of American quilts: design, pattern and color.