The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework-04, "Plain Quilting"
Publication Information
- Date Original
- 2005-03-21
- Contributor
- Barbara Brackman Legacy Project
- Location
- Lawrence, Kansas, United States
- Description
An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Needlework.
- Text File
- Transcript
March 21, 2005
The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework A Digital Newsletter © Barbara Brackman 2005 (For copyright information see the bottom of this message)
This is the fourth issue of a weekly digital newsletter, an update of the book Clues in the Calico. The first five issues, March, 2005, are sent as a free trial. If you would prefer to be removed from the subscription list just reply to this message and ask to be removed. If you want to continue your subscription in April and for the rest of 2005, please mail a check or money order for $36 to Barbara Brackman, PMB #C-237, 3115 W. 6th, Lawrence, KS, USA 66049) Remember when you are sending the check to put your email address on it. In some cases, I have no way to connect the email address with the check name and address.
- Plain Quilting Quilts not quilted with fancy motifs are generally quilted in one of two fashions. One is utility quilting, a repetitive design such as fans or diagonal lines, quilted across the top with little reference to the patchwork. The other follows the patchwork, for example outlining each piece about 1/4 of an inch away from the seam lines, a very popular mid-twentieth-century technique. This last technique is termed self-quilting or quilting by the piece. Techniques are often combined in one quilt. The blocks may be quilted by the piece and the borders quilted across the patchwork in a utilitarian grid.
Plain quilting is of little use in dating quilts since many of the patterns and styles developed early and are still in use. A few, however, are rather distinctive to specific eras. Quilting in the ditch (right in the seam lines) has been very popular since 1970 and may indicate an old top quilted at a later date. It's rare in antique quilts.
Fan Quilting. Fan quilting, a form of utility quilting in which groups of concentric arcs are quilted across the patchwork, appears to be a good clue to a post-1875 date. Earlier quiltmakers used this design, but were more likely to use it in combination with other motifs, for example as the quilting in a border. Because utility quilts are unlikely to be date-inscribed I had few examples in the database. Of the 16 with fan quilting, 13 were dated after 1900, indicating that fan quilting is most likely to be from the end of the nineteenth century or later. Other names for the design include English terms wave or sea wave quilting, rainbow or double rainbow quilting in Texas and elbow quilting in Tennessee (because the quilter uses the natural arc of her elbow to guide her.) Over the past twenty years, the names Baptist fan or Methodist fan have been popular, probably because the pattern was a favorite with church groups who quilted to raise money. This style of quilting, so common in the Midwest and South, seems unusual in antique New York and New England quilts.
Utility Quilting. Grids and parallel lines were the most popular form of nineteenth-century utility quilting and in general are no clue to date. Double and triple lines covering the top or a patchwork block, however, indicate a nineteenth-century piece, as the style is not common after 1900. Very close grids or lines, whether utility quilting or as filler behind fancy motifs, indicate a quilt from about 1800 to 1880. Nineteenth-century quilters often quilted parallel lines right over their appliqué blocks, a style that is rare after 1900, and surprises today's quilters who use quilting to emphasize the sculptural quality of the appliqué. The old-style utility quilting across the appliqué completely flattens the design.
Another popular mid-nineteenth-century style of plain quilting was chevrons or parallel lines laid out in angles, usually at ninety degrees. This style is still called elbow quilting in the South, but it is not often seen after 1900. A typical pieced quilt of 1850 might be quilted with lines about an inch apart, plotted to meet at right angles in the center of the block.
Echo quilting, in which the patchwork motif is ringed with concentric lines, is quite popular today. It was also popular in the nineteenth century. The general rule, the closer the quilting lines the more likely the quilt is to be 1800-1880, holds here. Other than that, echo quilting is not a clue to date. The name "echo quilting" is probably a contemporary term, something not used in the nineteenth or early twentieth century.
Rose Kretsinger in the 1935 book she co-wrote with Carrie Hall, The Romance of the Patchwork Quilt, gave names to a few of the utilitarian patterns. She showed right-angle elbow quilting but had no name for it. She called a diagonal grid the Square Diamond and a grid of double lines Plaid. She showed a pattern of curves that we usually call Clamshell today as the Shell. She also called a fan-quilted border a Shell design. Hanging Diamond was a grid in which one set of lines runs parallel to the edge of the quilt and the other crosses at a diagonal. The Hanging Diamond pattern across the entire quilt top was quite popular for plain quilts in the years 1890 to 1925.
Clues You Can Count On
- Fan quilting across the top of the quilt is a good indicator of a post-1880 date.
- "Quilting in the ditch," right in the seam lines of a pieced quilt, is a good indicator of a post-1970 date.
- Utility quilting right over the appliqué is a good clue to a nineteenth-century date.
References Carrie Hall and Rose Kretsinger, The Romance of the Patchwork Quilt (Caldwell, Idaho: Caxton Printers, 1935) Pages 271-272.
ATTACHMENT Capital T or Double T quilt, 1900-1925. This utilitarian quilt is quilted quite plainly with diagonal lines 1 1/2 inches apart across the blocks and a grid spaced 1 1/4 inches in the alternate plain blocks. There is some outline quilting about 1/4 inch away from the patchwork. The plain white border is quilted in parallel lines running perpendicular to the edge of the quilt 1 1/4 inches apart. This is the kind of quilting that was quite common at the turn of the last century, but it isn't distinctive enough to be a really good clue.
Links Several antique dealers have websites with photos of quilts that show some detail in the quilting. Susan Parrish's site www.susanparrishantiques.com/P4230.html features a chintz star quilt with elbow quilting in the star blocks. William Bunch antiques has a site www.williambunchauctions.com has an index called "Table of Categories." Go to Quilts and look at lot 751 for a good example of trapunto work discussed last week. Lot 768 and 815 have echo quilting. Lot 772 shows parallel lines.
If the links don't work (and they often don't) go to a search engine like google and type in the dealer's name. Follow from there looking for quilts. Most search engines include an image search. If you click on that pictures come up.
Advertising: Terry Clothier Thompson and I have a new collection of reproduction fabrics from Moda that should be in the quilt shops any day. Calico Craze celebrates America's fascination with small-scale dress prints after the Civil War. During the Calico Craze communities held calico balls, where women dressed in cotton dresses rather than the usual silk evening wear. Local fairs offered prizes for “the handsomest lady dress in calico” and the prettiest “calico babies.” After wartime scarcity of cotton fabrics, prices had dropped. In 1872, catalogs advertised these cotton prints, primarily manufactured in New England, at twelve yards for a dollar.
We’ve named the prints in our Calico Craze collection after the old fabric manufacturing mills that lined New England rivers. The collection focuses on the small-scale dress prints with a few added cretonnes (furnishing fabrics) and wovens, reflecting other fabrics of the era. The colors in the collection reflect the palette of the last quarter of the nineteenth century, when synthetic dyes formulated in test tubes were replacing natural dyes. New colorfast shades emphasized golden browns, olive greens and muted pinks and blues.
“Quite a large number assembled at the ‘Hall’ on Friday evening to enjoy the pleasure of the ‘Calico Carnival’ given by the Ladies’ Lyceum. According to the invitations many of the ladies were attired in calico while the gentlemen looked rather sporty with calico ties.” Newspaper account, Chester County, Pennsylvania, about 1900.
Copyright information. All rights to the text and information in this newsletter are reserved by Barbara Brackman. Subscribers may not forward the files or post the information on any websites or bulletin boards without written permission. You may quote up to four sentences without written permission Subscribers may print the files, save them digitally and refer to information if proper attribution is given. Please use the reference: "Barbara Brackman, The Quilt Detective: Clues in the Needlework, 2005, digital newsletter."
Page 3, Issue 4
- Object ID
- 64-193-5
Related Records