The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern-04, "Pattern Names: Fair Records & The Log Cabin"
Publication Information
- Date Original
- 2007-04-22
- Contributor
- Barbara Brackman Legacy Project
- Location
- Lawrence, Kansas, United States
- Description
An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Pattern.
- Text File
- Transcript
The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern A Digital Newsletter for 2007
© Barbara Brackman 2007 (For copyright information see the bottom of this message)
April 22, 2007 (delivered early on April 17)
4 Pattern Names: Fair Records & The Log Cabin
Like wills, agricultural fairs are public records. They can be found in the newspapers of the day and in summaries published by the agricultural boards that sponsored them. Quilts are commonly mentioned in the records, particularly after 1840 when the agricultural fair became a trend in public education. Specific pattern names, however, are uncommon as in the records of the 1870 Illinois State Fair, which listed numerous prize winners: "silk quilt", "patch-work quilt cover," and "cradle quilts." One exception was the "log quilt" pattern, also called "log cabin".
Reading the lists does occasionally reveal a specific pattern name. In 1853, the Illinois fair recorded a prize for a "bed quilt, box work." A Michigan State Fair in the mid- 1850s awarded Mrs. John Middleworth of Detroit a first prize for an "Odd Fellow's quilt patch work." We can guess what the log quilt and the box work (a tessellated diamond) looked like, but what was the Odd Fellow's quilt? Was it an appliqued design like those in the Baltimore Album quilts featuring symbols of the fraternal organization? Was it a pieced block like the attachment (antique11) called Odd Fellow, Odd Fellows Cross, Odd Fellow Patch in published name sources? Or was Odd Fellows another name for the quilt of many, many pieces described last week as Beggar's Blocks, Job's Troubles or Job's Tears?
Pattern Tracking: the Log Cabin Because it was so popular the Log Cabin's origins are relatively easy to track to the 1860s. Several examples are date-inscribed in the 1870s; the earliest date-inscribed example found so far is 1869. Local fair records are quite useful. Virginia Gunn found Log Cabins received a commendation at the Ohio State Fair in 1863 and again in 1868. In June of 1866, an Iowa diarist known only as "Abbie" wrote that she "went to town, bought Delaine for my log cabin." On the last day of July she "wrote a letter to Sis and worked on my log cabin." The pattern was so popular in the 1870-1900 period that fairs opened categories specifically for Log Cabin quilts.
We have a good idea what nineteenth-century quiltmakers called the pattern because the name Log Cabin also appears often in periodicals and personal writings. Log Cabin seems to be the standard, but the 1889 Ladies' Art Company pattern catalog called it the Log Patch. The British authors of an 1882 needlework manual noted that the design and technique were "well known in Canada under the name 'Loghouse Quilting' but only lately introduced in England.…This patchwork is more commonly known as Canadian patchwork." English names also include Egyptian or Mummy Pattern, referring to mummy wrappings of dark and light strips in a similar design.
The Log Cabin design is a good example of how an accurate history of patterns can conflict with romantic tales about the design. Over the past twenty-five years or so, a story has circulated that Log Cabin quilts were hung on clotheslines to alert runaway slaves to the presence of a "safe house." The published sources for this Log Cabin link are fairly recent. In 1990, folklorist Gladys-Marie Fry published Stitched From the Soul: Slave Quilts From the Antebellum South, illustrated with quilts attributed to enslaved seamstresses in museums and a few private collections. She captioned a Log Cabin from the collection of the Louisiana State Museum as made by “Dolly Jackson in Demopolis, Georgia 1860-1870.” Fry continues, “Log Cabin quilts containing black fabric often served as signals on the Underground Railroad to identify ‘safe houses.’” She includes no footnote. This caption appears to be the first published reference to the story of the log cabin as a signal quilt.
Characterizing Log Cabin quilts as part of the Quilt Code allegedly used during the decades of the Underground Railroad in the pre-Civil War period (1830-1861) presents many factual problems. The primary problem is that the pattern did not exist until after that period.
Log Cabins are best dated by the fabrics in them. As wools changed quality and silk prices varied, the look changed. In general the earliest Log Cabins (1860 to 1875) are of fine wools and wool combination fabrics. Cotton Log Cabin quilts tend to date from about 1870 or later. Silk Log Cabin quilts date from about 1880 to 1900 and Log Cabins pieced of heavy woolen fabrics tend to be from about 1900 to 1950.
The basic Log Cabin can be varied in many ways. The logs, the rectangular pieces, can "chase" each other around a square or butt against each other. The block can be shaded in many ways and the blocks set in common or quirky fashion. Names and origins for all the pattern variations are not so clear as the name and origins of the basic design.
Mystery Pattern: Halfalog det.jpg; Quarterlog.jpg A few years ago I came across the quilt in quarterlog.jpg on the internet and became fascinated by the pattern's visual appeal and the fact that it didn't have a "book name." People knew what I meant when I drew it out but the only thing I could come up with to describe it was a Quarter of a Log Cabin. The photo looked like the quilt had been made about 1900. Robert Bishop in his 1975 book New Discoveries in American Quilts had one from the same era which he called Log Cabin variation (page 69). Since then I've seen a few others made before 1925 and bought a top made in the 1940s (halfalog det.jpg)
Then I read The Quilts of Gee's Bend and found it was occasionally made in that small Alabama community where they call it Sweeps if it's a block by block set, or Plow Point if it's one big block. Paul Arnett writes, "The 'Plow Point' or 'Sweeps' variation 'Half-Log Cabin' in traditional quiltmaking terminology…looks like a quarter section of the traditional medallion…'Sweeps' blocks are typically presented in multiples…" (page 108)
Page 3, Issue 4
I don't know how "traditional" the name Half-Log Cabin is---or how old---but people seem to be using it right now. Designer Sharyn Craig has a how-to book The Ultimate Half Log Cabin Book. Half A Log is more melodious than the more accurate Quarter of A Log, I guess.
EBay Quilt of the Week Go to www.ebay.com and in the search box type the four words antique quilt log cabin. The design is one of the most common. You see some wonderful variations. The best one this morning is a striped silk one of indeterminate age in what we'd call the Housetops variation.
http://cgi.ebay.com/Antique-1880s-LOG-CABIN-Pattern-Satin-Silk-QUILT_W0QQitemZ110115057653QQihZ001QQcategoryZ2221QQrdZ1QQcmdZViewItem
Correspondence: Kimberly Wulfert identified the toile in the 1804 Orpah Harris quilt sent last week. She happened to be looking through Florence Montgomery's out-of-print Printed Textiles and found it on page 275 as the Birth of Venus, which Montgomery says was plate-printed in blue 1800-1805.
Links: International Quilt Study Center. Go to their home page at https://www.internationalquiltmuseum.org/ and click on the blue line that says "Search IQSC Collection." On the search page go to "Advanced Search and under the pull down menu that says Primary Pattern click on Log Cabin. They have quite a collection. Also try Log Cabin Variation and you'll see a great Half A Log Cabin by Augusta Duncan. Click on this URL to go directly to it. http://www.quiltstudy.org/search/index.html?search_type=advanced&search_action=advanced&totalresults=7&offset=0&maxresults=10&detailresult=3&sortby=PatternPrimary
To see many graphic variations of Log Cabin, particularly the Half a Log go to www.google.com and search for images. Type in the box Gees Bend Quilt and scroll around.
You may be aware of the internet project to digitize every book ever published. That goal is rather lofty but Google and the Making of America project are two sites working to achieve it. See what they have done in the way of published fair records by going to www.google.com On the right you will see the blue word More and click on that. A menu comes up so click on Books. You'll be at the Google Book Search page (Beta test). You have two options and you want to click on the button that says Full-view Books.
Then you are ready to search for any word in any of the thousands and thousands of books they have digitized. If you have all day you could search for quilt. But if you want to look at records of agricultural fairs try searching for the three words: Agricultural Board Record You'll get over 800 hits so scroll through them till you find something that looks like a list of fair records. I picked Transactions of the State Agricultural Society of Michigan http://books.google.com/books?vid=0WcwdBe-UI1DmBx7MTbM-PK&id=yGMMDp821HsC&pg=PA9&lpg=PA9&dq=agricultural+board+record&as_brr=1
Click on the book and you will see a pdf with the whole text. Now you want to search within that book. On the right is a list of options. At the bottom a search box. Type in quilt and hit go. Immediately below that a listing of the references to quilt will appear. Click on any of those dozens of references.
Michigan and Illinois seem to be the states best represented in this database, but you might check for your own by adding the state name to the search. I casually scrolled through and didn't find anything for mine.
And speaking of me I have a new web page. www.barbarabrackman.com
I'm going to try to change the quilt photos once a month or so to make it interesting.
References: John Beardsley, William Arnett et.al, The Quilts of Gee's Bend (Atlanta: Tinwood Books, 2002)
Gladys Marie Fry, Stitched From the Soul: Slave Quilts From the Antebellum South (New York: E.P. Dutton, 1990). Page 52.
Virginia Gunn, “Quilts at Nineteenth-Century State and County Fairs: An Ohio Study," Uncoverings 1988 (San Francisco: American Quilt Study Group, 1989) Pages 105-128.
Copyright information. All rights to the text and information in this newsletter are reserved by Barbara Brackman. Subscribers may print the files and save them digitally. Subscribers may not forward the files or post the information on any websites or bulletin boards without written permission. You may quote up to four sentences without written permission and refer to information if proper attribution is given. Please use the reference: "Barbara Brackman, The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern, 2007, digital newsletter."
Page 5, Issue 4
Attachments: antique 11.7 jacobs.jpg Two quilt tops from about 1850 and 1900 (on top) in variations of a common design with many names. Flying Geese and Jacob's Ladder are two; Odd Fellows is another.
delainelogmine.jpg Log Cabin top made of wool blends on a foundation. Estimated date: 1860-1880.I recently bought this small top which may have been intended to be a cradle quilt or a full-sized quilt never finished. I'm guessing it is one the early versions of the pattern because of the fabric---plaids and prints in wool delaines, bareges and challis, common dress fabric in the middle of the nineteenth century.
cohen's logcabin.jpg Log Cabin, estimated date 1880-1900. Collection of Rhoda Cohen. The picture looks out of focus but it's the plaids and polka dots in the arrangement we'd call Courthouse Steps.
ebaylogcabin.jpg Log Cabin, estimated date 1900-1950. I saw this quilt on eBay and loved the way she combined Log Cabin block structures.It's mostly Courthouse Steps (shaded concentrically with a light quarters and dark quarters) with a few Housetops (concentric shading in rings). Both names seem to be more in the vernacular than "book names" published before 1970. Housetops is another Gee's Bend name that has recently entered the common quilt vocabulary.
- Object ID
- 64-193-88
Related Records