The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern-14, "Pattern Distribution: Early Professional or Commercial Pattern Sources"
Publication Information
- Date Original
- 2007-07-01
- Contributor
- Barbara Brackman Legacy Project
- Location
- Lawrence, Kansas, United States
- Description
An issue of the weekly digital newsletter, updating the book Clues in the Calico, focusing on Pattern.
- Text File
- Transcript
The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern A Digital Newsletter for 2007
© Barbara Brackman 2007 (For copyright information see the bottom of this message)
July 1, 2007
14
Pattern Distribution: Early Professional or Commercial Pattern Sources
Quilters now obtain their patterns on paper---either bound into books and magazines or unbound "in the sheet," an old term for a single broadside type of printing. We know very little about how quiltmakers obtained their patterns before the 1880s. I can think of no surviving pattern cards or papers other than the few that were published in ladies' periodicals.
In the Ohio Quilt Research Project's book the authors addressed the issue of the missing quilt patterns.
"It is difficult to comprehend how nineteenth-century women achieved their consistent results without detailed instructions or patterns. However, their knowledge of new styles and techniques is not surprising when we examine how nineteenth century-women were accustomed to dealing with fashion changes. Not until the early 1870s were full-size paper dress patterns available."
We do find references to pattern drafters who sold designs for quiltmaking as well as other needlework, patterns that may have been hand drawn, printed on a sheet or published in a book. Abigaill Levy Franks who lived in colonial New York City was probably referring to embroidery designs in 1733 when she wrote a letter about daughter Phila who was learning Spanish and Hebrew. "I intend to send for some patterons for her to work opon next Summer."
Franks probably paid for the patterns, which had a monetary value as in a 1773 Maryland estate listing of "1 Patern of a Work'd Bed Quilt" worth a tenth of a pound. This design may have been for a wholecloth quilt as in an 1817 Lexington, Kentucky newspaper advertisement in which Mrs. Littleford described her school and mentioned that she offered "Toilettes and Coverlets drawn for work in the most elegant patterns." These last two references were uncovered by Paula Locklair who also describes several colonial American "pattern-drawers," a trade found in eighteenth-century England.
Lynn Zacek Bassett, an expert on New England quilts, has an online article about whole cloth wool quilts at www.antiquequiltdating.com in which she lists several references to artisans who rather than offering a paper pattern actually drew the quilting design on the cloth. Sarah Snell, for example, left an 1822 diary entry, “…went to Mr. Briggses to draw a feather on a bed quilt.” Sarah might have drawn patterns as a favor, for trade or for cash.
As pieced and appliqued quilts became more popular we find occasional references to the purchase of a patchwork pattern. In an 1835 diary entry Phoebe George Bradford of Wilmington, Delaware mentioned a Christmas bazaar. "We attended the fair of St. Andrew's Church….I bought a…pattern card for patchwork."
Attachments: This attachment and one in the next email show two nearly identical quilts. The major differences are in the shading of the sawtooth border (one points in; one points out) the leaf colors (one is green, one blue) the placement of the border foliage and the size which varies by inches.
Mus Amer Folk Art.jpg Unknown maker, attributed to Pennsylvania 1860-1880. 96" x 94" Collection of the Museum of American Folk Art.
Mystery Pattern The Flower of Paradise This is not a mysterious pattern or a one-of-a-kind quilt. The mystery here is why there are six nearly identical mid-nineteenth century quilts.
During the Kansas Quilt Project we had a documentation day in Topeka and two unrelated quiltowners amazed us by showing up with almost the same quilt. Each has five identical blocks bordered by a pieced sawtooth and an applique floral vine. The flowers in the outer border appear to be randomly placed but the randomness is rather planned with two flowers meeting in two corners of the border and lone flowers in the opposite corner.
While researching these twin quilts we found that they were quadruplets. The Museum of American Folk Art has an unattributed example with the same layout (see attachment) as does Franklin and Marshall College in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
The four became six when the Maryland project found two similar quilts. One is unattributed but one was well-documented and accompanied by a pattern block and a name----the family called it The Flower of Paradise. We would consider this a strange name for a design we easily call Whig or Democrat Rose or Rose of Sharon but the New York Project found a quilt of nine similar blocks that has the words "Flower of Paradise" inked on it. This corroboration of family name in Frederick County, Maryland and name actually on the quilt in Chautauqua County, New York upsets my ideas of what to call this very common design.
Nancy Hornback and Nancy Gibson Tuckhorn did quite a bit of genealogical research on the Kansas and Maryland quilts and found links to Frederick and Washington County in Maryland. The Maryland family's quilt square in the same design may be the method of pattern transmission. Rather than drawing a paper design, nineteenth-century quilters often passed finished blocks to friends and relatives. But one block does not explain the pattern similarities in sets and borders. We must assume the quilters drew their designs from the whole quilt.
The only quilt with a date inscribed on it is the New York project's Flower of Paradise which is inked March 28, 1862. This quilt is related by pattern name rather than identical pattern or set. The others are attributed to the years 1840-1880.
Page 3, Issue 14
Ebay Quilt of the Week Batavia sampler det2.jpg Someone had an impressive block collection for sale in June, several finished quilt tops with extra blocks that looked to be one woman's pattern collection made up in the 1930s or so. Some actually had names rather clumsily inked or embroidered on them. One block visible in the small jpg was the pattern we've been tracking all spring---the Apple Pie Ridge Star--- or is it the Kansas Pattern---or is it True Lover's Knot as written on this block.
Links For Lynn Bassett's article on whole cloth quilts http://www.antiquequiltdating.com/WoolWholeClothQuilts.html
The July 2-9 issue of U.S. News and World Report features "Secrets of the Civil War" with two columns by Diane Cole about the Quilt Code Controversy. They quoted several sources including me. See it at the link below. It's a pretty good summary of where the discussion stands right now---and where it's likely to stay. http://www.usnews.com/usnews/news/articles/070624/2quilts.htm
References: Gloria Allen and Nancy Tuckhorn, Maryland Album: Quiltmaking Traditions, 1634-1934 (Nashville: Rutledge Hill Press, 1995). Pages 150-152
Jacqueline M. Atkins & Phyllis A. Tepper, New York Beauties: Quilts from the Empire State (New York: Dutton, 1992). Page 112.
Paula W. Locklair. Quilts, Coverlets and Counterpanes: Bedcoverings from the Museum of Early Southern Decorative Arts and Old Salem Collections (Winston Salem: Old Salem, Inc. 1997) Pages 3-21.
Ricky Clark, George W. Knepper and Ellice Ronsheim, Quilts in Community: Ohio’s Traditions (Nashville: Rutledge Hill Press, 1991) Page 111.
Elizabeth V. Warren and Sharon L. Eisenstat, Glorious American Quilts: The Quilt Collection of the Museum of American Folk Art (new York: Penguin Stuido, 1996) Page 37
Copyright information. All rights to the text and information in this newsletter are reserved by Barbara Brackman. Subscribers may print the files and save them digitally. Subscribers may not forward the files or post the information on any websites or bulletin boards without written permission. You may quote up to four sentences without written permission and refer to information if proper attribution is given. Please use the reference: "Barbara Brackman, The Quilt Detective: Clues in Pattern, 2007, digital newsletter."
Koogle MD.jpg Flower of Paradise Quilt. Made by Malinda and Amanda Koogle, Frederick County, Maryland. Family history attributes it to about 1858. 93" x 93". This is the quilt that the family called Flower of Paradise.
shelburne botanical.jpg carolyn millers floral.jpg Here's another set of coincidences that upsets preconceived ideas---at least my preconceived ideas.
In issue # 6 on May 6 I described in detail a sampler in the Shelburne collection that had the names of the blocks inscribed. I wrote, "The more realistic blocks look to have been drawn from nature." This quilt looks so quirky I thought it had to be one of a kind.
But recently I was surfing through pictures of antique quilts on the web and came across this snapshot of an antique quilt Carolyn Miller owns. The quilts aren't identical but the blocks---many of which are odd--- are similar, the on-point set is the same and the thing that caught my eye was the half-wreaths in the border and the flowers in the corners. Carolyn's quilt has no writing on it. The Shelburne's is attributed by the dealer to Pennsylvania and Carolyn's has the cable quilting one often sees there.
I vaguely remember seeing a third one of these online but I don't recall where and Carolyn also said she'd heard there is a third.
- Object ID
- 64-193-97
Related Records